| Date |
Court |
Event |
| 1-Aug-05 |
CFI |
DSS Lodged initial infringement suit against ECB |
| 20-Oct-05 |
CFI |
ECB challenged Venue (wanted the suit to be heard in the European National Courts of each country instead of CFI) |
| 24-Mar-06 |
United Kingdom |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent |
| 24-Mar-06 |
Luxembourg |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent |
| March of 2006 |
The Netherlands |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent |
| March of 2006 |
Belguim |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent |
| March of 2006 |
France |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent |
| March of 2006 |
Spain |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent |
| March of 2006 |
Austria |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent |
| March of 2006 |
Germany |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent |
| March of 2006 |
Italy |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent |
| 30-Jan-07 |
United Kingdom |
Patent Invalidity Court Hearing concludes |
| 26-Mar-07 |
United Kingdom |
Court Decision release, patent revoked on basis of "added
matter" - All other challenges to patent were denied |
| 27-Mar-07 |
Germany |
Patent Invalidity Court hearing and decision, Court rules in DSS favor deeming Patent valid - Victory allows DSS to pursue infringement in Germany |
| 4-Jun-07 |
France |
Patent Invalidity court hearing |
| June of 2007 |
CFI |
Ruling on venue was delayed |
| 6-Sep-07 |
France |
First Delay - Expected to rule on Patent Validity hearing from
June 4, ruling delayed to Oct 24, 2007 |
| 11-Sep-07 |
CFI |
Ruling on Venue-CFI refuses jurisdiction. Sends jurisdiction to the European National Courts |
| 24-Oct-07 |
France |
Second Delay - Expected to rule on Patent Validity hearing from
June 4, ruling delayed to Nov 14, 2007 |
| 14-Nov-07 |
France |
Third Delay - Expected to rule on Patent Validity hearing from June 4, ruling delayed to January 9, 2008 |
| 14-Dec-07 |
The Netherlands |
Patent Invalidity Court Hearing |
| 9-Jan-08 |
France |
Court decision release-patent revoked on basis of "added matter" |
| 5-Feb-08 |
United Kingdom |
Hearing of Appeal |
| 19-Feb-08 |
The Netherlands |
Ruling was delayed until March 12, 2008 |
| February 2008 |
Italy |
Patent Invalidity court hearings [could range 4 - 7 hearings] |
| March 12, 2008 |
The Netherlands |
District Court of The Hague ruled patent valid |
| March 19, 2008 |
United Kingdom |
UK Court of Appeal upheld decision revoking Patent |
| June 3 & 5, 2008 |
Spain |
The Spanish trial was held on June 3rd and 5th with a summary hearing held on July 17,2008. |
| Sept 2008 |
Luxembourg |
The ECB has twice withdrawn its case in Luxembourg due to procedural irregularities. There are currently no proceedings in Luxembourg. |
| November 2008 |
Luxembourg |
ECB filed countersuit against DSS for invalidity of the patent for the third time. |
| 3-Apr-2009 |
Italy |
Patent Invalidity court hearing |
| Sept 2009 |
Belgium |
Patent Invalidity court hearing |
| October 2009 |
Austria |
Austrian validity hearing |
| Oct 30,2009 |
Belgium |
Patent revoked due to added matter |
| Oct 30,2009 |
Austria |
Patent revoked due to added matter |
| Dec 2009 |
France |
Invalidity Appeal Hearing |
| March 2010 |
France |
France Patent revoked by French Appeal Court |
| March 2010 |
Spain |
Court decides patent valid |
| June 2010 |
Netherlands |
Invalidity Appeal Hearing |
| July 2010 |
German |
Invalidity Appeal Hearing |
| January 2011 |
Netherlands |
Infringement Hearing |
|
|
|
